« Wife 1.0 | Main | My Favorite PowerPoint Resources »

Wednesday, June 23, 2004

Should You Get on the Blackberry Wagon?

A couple of months ago, I took my family to the beach for Spring Break. While I was there, I met a guy who was really sold on his Blackberry. (Actually, this is redundant. I’ve never met anyone who didn’t love their Blackberry. In fact, Blackberry users often refer to the device as a “Crackberry” because it’s so addictive.) I had seen them, of course, but this was the first time I ever saw one demonstrated. Being the gadget-guy that I am, I thought, I’ve gotta have one.

Immediately upon my return to work, I contacted my IT department and told them I wanted to order ten test units that we could try for a month. I’ve bought enough gadgets in the past to know that not many of them have any real utility once the initial wow-sensation has passed. I thought that if the Blackberry could survive the scrutiny of my ten top executives for 30 days, it might be worth adopting the technology.

The Blackberry I saw on my vacation had a color screen, so I was a little let down when I received my test unit which had a black-and-white screen. However, I started using the gadget and quickly forgot about the color. Research in Motion, the manufacturer of the Blackberry, has developed some wonderfully elegant usability features. Here are my favorites:

  • Up-to-date connectivity. Your e-mail and calendar changes are “pushed” to the device as soon as they hit your Exchange server (this is the back-end technology that allows Outlook users to communicate with each other within a company). In some cases, I have had e-mails show up on my Blackberry before they appeared on my TabletPC. If your assistant makes a change to your calendar, you know about it instantly.

  • Intuitive point-and-click hardware. The trackwheel on the right-side of the Blackberry is the primary means you use to navigate. It’s like a thumb-operated mouse. I found it to be very natural and intuitive. To select an item, you push the trackwheel. Another button, right next to the trackwheel functions as an escape key. There's also a Phone button that enables you to instantly go to the phone screen to make a call. Here’s what it looks like:

    Blackberry

  • A usable thumb-sized keyboard. The Blackberry has a keyboard you can actually use. I wasn’t sure I could actually type with my thumbs, but surprisingly, on the Blackberry, this is very easy. In fact—and don’t tell my wife—I can now do this with one hand in the car! (By the way, while testing the Blackberry, I also tested the Treo 600 side-by-side with it. There’s no comparison. In my opinion, the Treo is “all show and no go.” I liked the phone better, but the keyboard is impossible. Your mileage may vary.)

  • Smart software. Simply click on a e-mail address, phone number, or URL to automatically begin composing an e-mail, place a call, or visit a Web page. The AutoText feature replaces certain phrases or words with whatever you want to attach to it. This is similar to Microsoft Word’s AutoCorrect feature or to ActiveWords (though not as sophisticated). This is particularly helpful, since you are typing with your thumbs. For example, if you type two spaces in a row, AutoText will automatically insert a period and a space. It will also automatically capitalize the beginning of a sentence. My favorite feature is the automatic insertion of hypens in contractions. If I enter “didnt”, AutoText will automatically enter “didn’t”. This makes text-entry very fast. (The Treo, by the way, has nothing like this—not even from a third-party developer.)

  • Integrated attachment viewing. You don’t have to purchase additional software to view attachments. This is included out of the box. You can view spreadsheets and documents by simply clicking on the attachment.

For many, the big question is how this technology integrates into David Allen’s Getting Things Done methodology. Simply put, it doesn’t. Referring to one of his coaching clients, David says,

He tossed his Blackberry (“Crackberry” as he called it!), agreeing with my recommendation that e-mail should be processed most efficiently for most people from at least a laptop, and he ordered a Palm to distribute his Outlook lists into for portability.

With all due respect to David, I think this misses the point. The Blackberry is not a replacement for your normal Getting Things Done system. The task categories don’t sync between Outlook and the Blackberry, so using it as David recommends you use a Palm is not an option. However, this doesn’t mean the Blackberry should be tossed.

The value of the Blackberry to me is for quick e-mail and calendar reference. This comes in handy when I am in the car or on a plane and pulling out my TabletPC is too much trouble. I don’t do a lot of e-mail processing on the Blackberry. But for the occassional quick e-mail, when business is moving at the speed of light, a Blackberry is very handy.

For example, last night I had a business dinner meeting. However, I got the time wrong and arrived at the restaurant 30 minutes early. Fortunately, I had my Blackberry, so I made good use of the time. I was able to respond to several urgent e-mails that kept things moving along. If I had not had my Blackberry, or if I had just brought a Palm, I would have been out of luck. I could have reviewed my lists and seen what I needed to do, but it would have been difficult to get any actual work done.

If the point of Getting Things Done is, well, to get things done, then the Blackberry is worthy of consideration. It enables me to get important things done that would otherwise have to wait until I returned to my computer. Also, since it doubles as a phone, I’m not carrying any more devices than I used to. All told, I’m very pleased.

June 23, 2004 at 12:02 PM in Cool Gadgets, Getting Things Done | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83452682569e200e55071a8a48834

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Should You Get on the Blackberry Wagon?:

» Michael Hyatt: from Loosely Coupled
[Read More]

Tracked on Jun 29, 2004 12:36:13 AM

Comments

I have a Treo 600. All my friends with Blackberrys envy my Treo. Everything, other than the push E-Mail, works better on the Treo.

The Treo really is the amplification of aggregating innovative ideas inside a handheld device.

I think that the Good Technology folks have an enterprise soluton that pushes and syncs Outlook events with Exchange. I know that they have some great people working for them, but I haven't tried their solution.

I seem to sense that those people who use a Blackberry do so in part because it has imposed upon them, and if given a choice would pick the Treo.

Posted by: Buzz Bruggeman | Jun 23, 2004 1:05:03 PM

Michael: My experience trial-ing the Blackberry led me to many of the same conclusions you've come to. I ended up not keeping it for two reasons: First, we don't use Exchange at my company so much of the goodness of the Blackberry was not available to me. Second, the lack of categories made it cumbersome to use the Blackberry as the only device I carry (which was my goal). But it is an effective tool. And with apologies to my friend Buzz, the Treo's thumboard is a deal-killer for me. My thumbs are too big for its tiny keys.

Posted by: Marc Orchant | Jun 23, 2004 1:19:53 PM

As I mentioned in the article, I tested the Blackberry and the Treo at the same time. I used both for 30 days. We used the Sprint Connection server software, which pushed my e-mail and calendar entries to me, just as the Blackberry does. However, I found the keyboard unusable and the software interface too clumsy. The phone was definitely better on the Treo, but that was the only advantage I found. Everything else took too many steps and was not intuitive. This is just my experience -- yours is obviously different.

Posted by: Michael Hyatt | Jun 23, 2004 2:10:18 PM

I'm a confirmed Palm fan (and GTD neophyte). Since I'm another confirmed gadget-guy, I'm waiting for the blackberry to be available in my part of the world so I can give it a good trial.

Until then, the Tungsten T3 gives me all the PDA functions I need, and since it has bluetooth as well (as does my phone) if I have 30 minutes to kill, I can still do email, some light web browsing, as well as the more normal PDA functions. Hell, if I'm feeling sufficiently masochistic, I can even ssh into a server and do systems administration type work.

Personally, I prefer convergence enabling technology (like bluetooth) over converged devices (like the Treo and the blackberry) - this way, I have the freedom to leave the PDA at home and the cellphone (nice and small) sits in a pocket without interfering too much with what I'm trying to do.

It's all about the freedom.

Posted by: Malach | Jun 23, 2004 4:37:24 PM

I have an i-mate pocket pc phone. This is the only device that I carry with me at all times. I don't use it for work per se. Meaning, I don't care to read my work-related emails on my i-mate.

I work at a company where I am at my desk in front of a PC about 80% of the time. The rest of the time is spent in meetings. So, I read and respond to my work-related emails at my desk.

But what is useful for me is to be able to get and respond to my personal emails. My company does not allow you to check your personal email accounts. I have a Yahoo account. My i-mate checks and downloads my new emails every 15 minutes. This value can be configured to check for new mail every minute or whatever value you want. So, this is sort of like the blackberry's "push" email concept.

Posted by: Jonathan | Jun 23, 2004 6:03:18 PM

Michael,

I use my i-mate to process my personal emails - GTD style - as they arrive throughout the day. If it is junk email or not important, it gets deleted. If it is reference emails, I will remember to file it away in a specified folder when I get home to redownload the emails to my desktop Outlook. If there is an action item involved and it is more than 2 minutes, I will put it in the proper projects or categories. It saves me a ton of time when I get home because all of the front-end decision making has already been made during the day. At home, I will redownload all of my emails that I received during the day that were not deleted (on my i-mate) to my desktop PC and file them accordingly.

Posted by: Jonathan | Jun 23, 2004 6:50:53 PM

Michael, I really enjoy your detailed entries about your experience using various technologies in pursuit of productivity enhancement. In fact, your entry on the Blackberry inspired me to write about how I measure the value of the tools that we use.

For me, the measure of success in evaluating a new technology or productivity tool is the degree to which it becomes transparent to the actual work being done, and the level of productivity that is gained as a result. A doctor should not have to think about his scalpel or stethoscope; neither should a writer have to think about his pen or legal pad.

In the same way, a knowledge worker should not have to think about his information processing tools. Any time he does, he robs himself of the opportunity to get his real work done.

I've blogged in response to your post at: http://www.ericmackonline.com/emo/emonline.nsf/dx/what-value-wireless-e-mail

Thanks for sharing!

Eric Mack

Posted by: Eric Mack | Jun 24, 2004 3:01:12 PM

Michael,

I've just completed a BlackBerry instructional tri-fold for one of my clients who are currently testing the BlackBerry with their sales staff - if you would like a copy of it I'd be pleased to email it to you (it's in Word format so you could even adapt it for your business if you wish, no problem, just let me know.

Anyway, the purpose of this post is to say that the one concern I have with the BB is that it can become a 'divorce' gadget if abused! As well as getting used to the technology for communicating with and reviewing your emails, you also have to know when to 'switch it off'. Otherwise, there is a danger of it taking over your personal life as well as your professional life.

Excellent blogs by the way!
Regards,
Barry

Posted by: Barry Galvin | Jun 26, 2004 1:36:06 PM

Hey Michael, time to rewrite your BB article... ;) => BB categories are there in V4. Now it is greatly usable (still can't do the Project/NA distinction), and no more 120 non-categorized tasks.^&*( And maybe one of you has an idea how to implement the GTD add-in Project/Action concept with it??)
I enjoy this site and the tips. Thank you! Falk Willis

Posted by: Falk Willis | Dec 1, 2004 11:22:43 PM

I work for an IT Solutions provider called IT Weapons. Every employee we have uses the RIM device, and enjoy the benefits of BES 4.0's "cradle-less" syncing.

We're the kind of company that says "If we wouldn't use it, we won't offer it to our customers", plain and simple. Now that I have this capability I can't comprehend how I survived without this type of technology. There are many more options to this type of device. Imagine querying Goldmine through your Blackberry, processing the order and completing the sale - right there at the the meeting! That's an offering from AppSwing that integrates with you RIM device. Just an example of course.

But if your the type that likes to be productive and mobile at the same time, that's a solution for you.

Love the articles...

Posted by: AdamStac | Mar 25, 2005 9:36:13 AM

Post a comment